If a Manager Asks You to Do Something That You Disagree With, What Would You Do?

If a Manager Asks You to Do Something That You Disagree With, What Would You Do?

Have you ever been in an awkward situation with a manager where they ask you to do something, but you know it’s not right? This happens all the time! Just because your manager is your superior does not mean that they are always going to have the best answers. In this article, you will learn what to do if a manager asks you to do something that you disagree with.

It’s great to trust your manager and listen to what they say, but that doesn’t mean you follow them blindly. In fact, a good manager will thrive on the support that the team offers when constructively challenging their decisions. This question is not designed to see whether you would do immoral or illegal activities for your manager. The intention is to judge your ability to react to a conflicting situation.

Whatever this manager is asking you to do, it is important that you express your concerns in a non-threatening way, and try to offer a solution that would make both parties happy.

How You Should Answer – Sample

“It depends entirely on what you are asking me to do. If you told me to do something that contradicts my moral beliefs, I would try my best to explain my feelings to you and then find a solution we both agree with. If I just disagreed with the way my manager was doing something, I would politely recommend an alternative way and explain its advantages. Regardless of the situation, I would take a closer look at what is being asked and figure out a solution to achieve the same results without contradicting my moral beliefs.”

For everything you could ever need to know about interviewing, check out the 50 Top Job Interview Questions And Answers.

Focus points

Notice that this person never told their manager NO (at least not yet). There is a much better way to go about this then just defying your boss. Make sure to propose a better solution if there is any. If you have laid out a better solution and your manager is still asking you to do things a certain way, then you should trust your superior and follow his or her instructions. At that point, they will be the ones held responsible if anything goes wrong.

However, if you are still being asked to do something immoral or illegal after you have explained that you are uncomfortable performing this act, it is time to take your concerns to HR. If your manager is out of line, it’s probably best that he/she gets reported anyway. You will be doing yourself and your future coworkers a favor.

P.S. We Love You

Interviewing can be a serious roadblock during the hiring process. There is nothing worse than spending hours to find and apply for jobs online, receive a call for an interview, and then completely tank it. What a waste of time! At Find My Profession we offer expert interview training, so that doesn’t happen to you!

  • Companies Known for Their Great Work-life Balance

    Companies Known for Their Great Work-life Balance

    When it comes to your career and your life, finding a company with great work-life balance is essential.You want to find a company that challenges you to grow professionally but doesn't leave you without time or energy for other activities. Check out these companies who are known for their great worklife balance.

    Kelli Lafont by Kelli Lafont
    Read On
  • Are You Adding as Much Value as You Think

    Are You Adding as Much Value as You Think

    Only 21% of employees feel strongly valued at work. Typically, your personal opinion of your value at work is comprised of income and recognition. Although employers seem to be behind the 8-ball when it comes to recognizing performance, it has been more and more of a focus of many companies in recent years.

    Seth Stoker by Seth Stoker
    Read On
  • What to Say About Your Weaknesses in a Job Interview

    What to Say About Your Weaknesses in a Job Interview

    I dislike the question, "What are your weaknesses?". Like many similar interview questions and scenarios, this question encourages play-acting. It's not a good way to get insight on the candidate or encourage open communication. Instead, it tests if the job candidate if you know what to say about your weaknesses in a job interview.

    Connor Clark by Connor Clark
    Read On
See All Articles