Describe a Time When Your Work Was Criticized?

Describe a Time When Your Work Was Criticized?

Behavioral interview questions can be some of the hardest questions to answer. Often times, there is no right or wrong answer. It’s how you frame your answer and what you learned from the experience that is important. When being asked to describe a time when your work was criticized, there are a few key points to emphasize and some obvious mistakes to avoid.

Why am I being asked this question?

The secret here is not to avoid answering the question. Believe it or not, you should answer this question with an honest critique that someone made about your work. Whether it was a valid critique or not is another topic. The employer is looking to judge your ability to handle criticism. Did you get angry and use profanity with the person critiquing you? Or did you own up to your fault and develop a way to improve your work to avoid criticism in the future. These are all part of the 50 Top Job Interview Questions And Answers.

Do's

  • Give a real-life example. Explain a situation where a real person gave you a real critique.
  • Make yourself come off as coachable. Instead of being defensive, use this opportunity to show your critic that you are willing and eager to learn and improve.
  • Try to give an example that has a positive outcome. If your story starts with someone criticizing you, it should end with your success in improving your performance.

Do not's

  • Don’t lie! Never make up a story for a hiring manager. The fact is if you just prepare for the interview questions you will never need to lie.
  • Focus on the positive outcome. Do not talk poorly about the person criticizing you. Give an example where you improved what was criticized. Don’t give an example where the critic was actually wrong with their criticism and you were right.
  • Don’t avoid the answer. Saying that you have never been criticized is foolish. If you can’t think of a work example, think of a school project, internship, etc.

Sample answer

“Being only human, I can definitely admit to having received criticism of my work in the past. The only thing you can do at that point is to thank the person for pointing out the flaw. Some people don’t like when you tell them they have food on their face. I see it as a way to prevent them from future embarrassment from someone other than myself.

Last year, I received criticism from a co-worker on my report writing. She did not like how I sent each report in a separate email. Instead, she requested that all emails be sent in one email. I had no idea this was what she preferred. As soon as she told me I was easily able to make the change by compiling all documents into one email. Ever since then, everything has been fantastic between the two of us.”

P.S. We love you

While we are being honest with one another, let’s be honest about the whole job finding process. It stinks! If you need some extra help landing your dream career, let the pros at Find My Profession help.

  • How to Avoid Backfill Hell

    How to Avoid Backfill Hell

    She announced she was leaving work. Sure I said. Need to leave early? No problem. Everything caught up? But she meant she leaving as in quitting. Hiring her finally made my team full. And I had a very lean team already. I was wrong. Learn how you can stay out of backfill hell as a leader.

    Mateo Solero by Mateo Solero
    Read On
  • Having Trouble Filling Key Roles?  Review Your Selection Process

    Having Trouble Filling Key Roles? Review Your Selection Process

    If you are having trouble filling key roles at your company, maybe the reason is not a shortage of talent in the marketplace, but that your selection process is too rigid.  While you should always strive to hire the most technically qualified person for each job opening, today's tight job market makes it tough to find suitable candidates who "check all the boxes" on your job specifications.

    Mike Sweeny - MAS Recruiting by Mike Sweeny - MAS Recruiting
    Read On
  • Advice for Women in the Tech Industry

    Advice for Women in the Tech Industry

    Women are outnumbered in many workplaces, but especially in the tech industry. A 2017 study by Observer, showed some statistics to explain just how outnumbered women are at all levels of the tech industry. Given the disturbing stats, we offer this advice for women interested in the tech industry but believe the obstacles are too tough to overcome.

    Find My Profession by The FMP Contributor
    Read On
See All Articles