Best Columbus Career Coach Badge 2023

2023 Winners: Add your badge to your marketing materials.

Columbus is a diverse city, and so is its job market.

The city is teeming with industries in all sectors that attract people from around the nation and the world.

Living in Ohio’s state capital does not mean your career path is perfectly laid out. In fact, you might be facing huge challenges in finding the right job.

Luckily, there are career coaches who can help you with everything from identifying your career goals to researching prospects to support you throughout the job-hunting process.

We’ve taken the time to research career coaching services in Columbus to bring you only the most skilled. 

Below, we’ve compiled a list of some of the best career coaching services in Columbus.

Best Career Coaches in Columbus

Find My Profession
Find My Profession Best Overall More Details
Worthington Career Services Multi-Certified Coach More Details
Nolan Branding 800x474
Nolan Branding Most Affordable More Details
4
4
Crosworks Career & Talent Strategists 20+ Years Experience More Details
5
5
First Penguin Coaching Certified Coach More Details
6
Briefcase Coach
6
Briefcase Coach More Details
7
7
Renegade More Details

How We Choose Winners

Each of the Columbus career coaching services below was reviewed taking into consideration the following:

Cost

The cost of the service compared to other Columbus career coaches.

Credentials

Overall experience, awards, and certifications.

Process

Effectiveness of the process from start to finish.

Reviews

Client reviews on third-party platforms.

This list was hand-curated to serve all industries, professions, and career levels. While many of the services on this list are from Columbus, these career coaches are virtually available whether you are in Cincinnati, Akron, Cleveland, Fort Wayne, Lincoln Village, Bexley, Dayton, Parma, or Toledo.

Average Columbus Coaching Cost

Columbus Career Coaching Cost
$7250
$100
$13500
average mark
low average high

Columbus Career Coach Reviews

1

Find My Profession

Find My Profession offers a one-of-a-kind experience that goes far beyond any other career coaching service on this list.

While traditional career coaches will teach you how to find a job, Find My Profession’s Reverse Recruiting service will do the work for you.

This white-glove service will search for jobs on your behalf, apply for you with a customized resume to fit the application, and network with key decision-makers to secure interviews.

The only thing they won’t do is show up to the interview for you. But don’t worry, this service includes interview preparation to make sure you’ll crush any interviews they land you.

PROS

You can save hundreds of hours searching for jobs, filling out applications, customizing your resume, and networking. Finally, you can pay someone to find you a job. Your dedicated Reverse Recruiter will create a personalized strategy to manage all aspects of your job search. Each Reverse Recruiter only works with four clients at a time, providing you with personalized attention and care.

CONS

If you’re looking for a traditional career coach to help you change career paths, this service may not be a good fit. The Reverse Recruiting service is for professionals who know what kind of job they want but don’t have the time or energy to find it on their own. There is also usually a waitlist of about one month.

REVIEWS

4.9/5 based on 394 Trustpilot reviews
4.9/5 based on 276 Sitejabber reviews
5/5 based on 147 Google reviews
5/5 based on 53 Facebook reviews
5/5 based on 8 BBB reviews
5/5 based on 4 Yelp reviews

COST

$2,500 per 4-week period

CONTACT

(831) 888-0967 or help@findmyprofession.com

Check out some of our 5-star reviews:

Excellent service provided

[Reverse Recruiter] is by far the best career finder I have ever had to pleasure to work with. He truly goes above and beyond in everything he does when he works with you, and the results definitely show it. He was professional throughout the entire experience. His attention to detail, overall industry knowledge, and the way he takes care of his clients is best in class. Also, turnaround time and email responses were done very quickly. If you don’t work with [Reverse Recruiter] for your career finder/job search needs, you’re missing out big time! Can’t thank him enough for everything he has done.

Outstanding service

I had the opportunity to work with [Reverse Recruiter], and I must say the experience was excellent. The communication was great, the level of professionalism and effectiveness was very high, from identifying the right jobs to networking with the right people in LinkedIn! I highly recommend this service to anyone in a senior position who is serious about finding a new job. Take it from me, you can not do it better yourself.

Find My Profession review

Working with [Reverse Recruiter] and Find My Profession reminds of the raptures in the film Jurassic Park. They were relentless in all aspects of my job search. I understand that your spouse or others may question the cost but it was worth every penny. ABSOLUTELY RECOMMEND!

Worth the investment

I used the Find My Profession service to rewrite my resume and to revamp my Linkedin page. I also used the Find My Profession career finder service and worked with [Reverse Recruiter] to help me apply for roles and market my profile to potential employers. [Reverse Recruiter] worked very diligently to ensure that my profile was marketed to top-level executives in my industry and his efforts eventually led to my finding the perfect role which I received a great offer and that I accepted. This is a great service and I believe it is worth the investment for those who are looking to find their next role.

FMP – landed me the job!

From the very beginning of my initial application, it was clear [Reverse Recruiter] was here to help me in the next stages of my career journey. This wasn’t going to be an ordinary job search experience. Based on our enrollment conversation, [Reverse Recruiter] took the lead managing the job search process for me. She asked the right number of questions to build the search criteria specific to my interests (role, industry, location). [Reverse Recruiter] scanned the horizon weekly and staged available opportunities reducing my effort/stress and allowing focus on my personal and family obligations. Upon my giving a prospective position the green light, [Reverse Recruiter] submitted a tailored application on my behalf and followed up with the employer as necessary. Along the way, [Reverse Recruiter] freshened my resume and online profile to take advantage of today’s job search criteria. She also expanded my LinkedIn presence connecting me with dozens of professionals. Above all, [Reverse Recruiter] listened carefully to my evolving needs and adjusted the job search process accordingly. It was as if [Reverse Recruiter] was personally committed to helping me find the right match (which she did!). Depending on your time and energy available, Find My Profession team members can either take full lead on the job search process or can supplement your existing plan. Don’t go it alone.

Great service for busy…

I am so pleased with my experience with [Reverse Recruiter] at FMP. I was looking to change industries, but too busy and overwhelmed with my day-to-day to embark on the journey on my own. No only did he do the heavy lifting with applications, but was a readily available resource in coaching to ensure I nailed interviews and marketed myself in the best way possible. He was helped to give me realistic expectations without short-changing myself or my skills to get the job I wanted. Thanks to him, I was able to secure a great role at my dream company within 6 weeks!

[Reverse Recruiter] was…

[Reverse Recruiter] was hard working and excellent and he directly led to me finding a job in 30 days! It was a pleasure to have him behind the scenes finding opportunities.

Excellent Service!

I started using the Career Finder service on July 16th, and a month later on August 16th, I was offered a job! I really appreciated [Reverse Recruiter’s] guidance and expertise through this process. It had been 18 years since I’d had to job search, and had no idea where to start. While the price was high, I thought if this service shortened my job search by a few months, then it would be worth it. [Reverse Recruiter] was very skilled in networking, helping me find positions that were of interest, but weren’t necessarily ones I would have looked for myself, applying, (and outside his job description), dealing with my emotions as I got rejections, and became frustrated trying to figure out what I was searching for. The position I landed was something that I probably wouldn’t have thought to look at myself. I appreciate how fast I was able to find something that I feel like will be a great fit, and I would highly recommend [Reverse Recruiter] and this service.
2

Worthington Career Services

Worthington Career Services is an award-winning (and Ohio’s highest rated) career coaching and job search firm. Their team of seasoned resume writers, career coaches, and corporate recruiters have a combined experience of over 30 years. Janice Worthington is the executive director at Worthington Career Services.

PROS

Janice is an Executive Career Coach with four decades of experience. She is a Certified Employment Interview Professional (CEIP) and a Certified Job and Career Transition Coach (JCTC). She is also a member of the Professional Association of Resume Writers & Career Coaches (PARWCC).

CONS

The website lacks detailed information about the career coaching packages. This may not be the best service for you if you’re looking for a traditional career coach to help with your career transition. Also, they do not offer many coaching programs.

REVIEWS

5/5 based on 151 Google reviews

COST

$250 – $295 per session, $6,500+ for comprehensive packages

CONTACT

(614) 890-1645 or jeremy@worthingtonresumes.com

Best Agencies That Help You Find Jobs

Need Help With Your Job Search?

Did you know there are companies you can hire to help with your job search? Whether you need resume help or want someone to apply to jobs for you, we’ve reviewed the 20 best agencies to help you find a job.

3

Nolan Branding

Nolan Branding is one of the most accomplished personal branding firms in the U.S., having worked with more than 9,000 clients in over 47 states. They provide career coaching services for individuals, employers, and organizations. Samantha Nolan founded the company in the year 2000 as a corporate design firm named Ladybug Design.

PROS

Nolan Branding boasts a close-knit team of industry-leading experts who specialize in resume writing, LinkedIn profile makeover, career coaching, interview coaching, and more. Samantha is an expert writer and career strategist who helps her clients climb the career ladder through personal branding services.

CONS

The website says they are an elite team of skilled and experienced career professionals, but we cannot find any details about any career coaches working at the company other than Samantha Nolan.

REVIEWS

5/5 based on 24 Google reviews

COST

$199 per session

CONTACT

(614) 570-3442 or admin@nolanbranding.com

4

Crosworks Career & Talent Strategists

Crosworks is a well-knit team of career professionals and talent strategists who have demonstrated an excellent track record of success across a variety of organizations. Shelly Stotzer is the owner and MD at Crosworks, where she uses her extensive experience and coaching expertise to help clients move forward.

PROS

Crosworks provides career coaching services to both individuals and businesses. Shelly is a skilled career and executive coach and a Certified Birkman Consultant with over 20 years of experience. Crosworks strategists hold industry leading certifications from across a wide range of well-respected organizations.

CONS

There are no coaching packages available to buy directly on the website. You have to contact Crosworks to learn more about their pricing plans, process, and timing before getting started.

REVIEWS

5/5 based on 23 Google reviews

COST

~$200+ per hour

CONTACT

(614) 538-2808 or info@crosworks.com

5

First Penguin Coaching

First Penguin offers customized career coaching services depending on an individual’s unique needs. They empower individuals by identifying their skills, interests, and values to help plan their career path ahead. Gina Studer is the owner of First Penguin and a Certified Career Management Coach who serves clients nationwide.

PROS

Depending on your career goals, they offer personalized coaching sessions, from career clarity coaching to job search strategy coaching to career success coaching. Gina works with career professionals of every experience level and across all industries to help determine their next step.

CONS

We could not find any details regarding the pricing of the coaching programs. You have to schedule a call with Gina to get a quote. Also, the services are not backed by any guarantees.

REVIEWS

5/5 based on 7 Google reviews

COST

~$100+ per hour

CONTACT

(614) 327-9071 or gina@firstpenguincoaching.com

6

Briefcase Coach

Briefcase Coach offers executive resume writing, interview coaching, and corporate outplacement services to clients nationwide. Sarah Johnson is the founder of Briefcase Coach. She was a LinkedIn Top Voice in the career space in 2019 and one of the HR Weekly’s 100 Most Influential People in HR Globally.

PROS

Sarah offers career development coaching and executive coaching services nationwide. She has assisted many executive career transitions including CEOs, VPs, sales directors, and more. Her work has been featured in Forbes, Inc, and Mac’s list.

CONS

Sarah specializes in job search and interview coaching sessions. So, if you’re looking for more personalized coaching services, you may want to consider another option. Also, she does not offer in-person visits.

REVIEWS

5/5 based on 2 Google reviews

COST

$219 per 60-minute session or $295 per 90-minute session

CONTACT

(614) 706-3788 or sarah@briefcasecoach.com

Resume Writing Services

Is Your Resume Working Properly?

If you are having trouble landing interviews, it might be time to hire a professional resume writer. Check out our list of the 750+ best resume writers and start landing more interviews!

7

Renegade

Renegade is a human innovation company founded by Amy Jo Martin. Regan Walsh, an Executive Coach in Columbus, leads the programming for Renegade. They empower individuals and corporations to succeed in the workplace. They provide leadership training to women “ready to get their hands dirty”!

PROS

Amy Jo Martin has been featured in recognized news outlets including the Harvard Business Review, Huffington Post, AdWeek, and Sports Business Journal. In addition to corporate solutions, Renegade offers an extensive leadership program for female leaders, entrepreneurs, and executives around the world.

CONS

Renegade is not a typical career coaching company. Also, the Renegade Accelerator program is for female leaders only. Amy Jo has worked with world-renowned brands, but she doesn’t have any industry-standard certifications in career coaching or career counseling.

REVIEWS

Not found

COST

$13,500 per year

CONTACT

info@amyjomartin.com

Previous Years Winners

Career Coaching Winners (2022)

Find My Profession, Worthington Career Services, Nolan Branding, Crosworks Career & Talent Strategists, First Penguin Coaching, Briefcase Coach, Renegade